Arrangement
Fredsbevarande operasjonar: Korleis måle suksess (og fiasko)?
NUPI har gleda av å invitere til ope seminar med professor Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé frå Bishop's University i Canada. Ho er aktuell med boka Evaluating Peacekeeping Missions, der ho bruker funn frå feltarbeid til å skape nye måtar å evaluere fredsbevarande operasjonar på. Forfattaren peikar på to ulike suksessfaktorar: å halde oppe den etablerte ordenen i området til fredsoperasjonen, og å tilfredsstille mandatet til operasjonen.
Med utgangspunkt i FN-operasjonane i Somalia, Sierra Leone og Liberia, avviser Martin-Brûlé klassifiseringa av konteksten desse har funne stad i som den verst tenkjelege når det gjeld overgangspolitikk. I staden viser ho at fredsoperasjonar heilt eller delvis kan lykkast sjølv i utfordrande kontekstar. Om ein operasjon er "vellykka" eller "dårleg" kan forklarast med kven som intervenerer og kva strategi som blir nytta, heller enn med kva kontekst intervensjonen gjekk føre seg i.
Martin-Brûlés forsking viser at for ein fredsoperasjon i ein sivil konflikt, verkar ein forhindringsstragegi best for å få retta opp igjen orden, mens ein stormaktsintervensjon ofte har betre effekt når det gjeld å tilfredstille mandatet til operasjonen.
For meir informasjon, sjå Dr. Martin-Brûles nye bok Evaluating Peacekeeping Missions, gitt ut på Routledge.
Du kan følgje seminaret direkte på YouTube
Taler
Ordstyrer
Relaterte publikasjoner
Why Consider New Approaches to Peacebuilding and Evaluation, and Why Turn to Complexity for Answers?
Complexity Thinking for Peacebuilding Practice and Evaluation
This book addresses the core dilemma that practitioners have to confront: how to function in situations that are fast changing and complex, when equipped with tools designed for neither? How do we reconcile the tension between the use of linear causal logic and the dynamic political transitions that interventions are meant to assist? Insights from Complexity Thinking for Peacebuilding Practice and Evaluation covers the design, evaluation, and learning for international interventions aiming to promote peace. More specifically, it reconceptualises this space by critically analysing mainstream approaches – presenting both conceptual and empirical content. This volume offers a variety of original and insightful contributions to the debates grappling with the adoption of complexity thinking. Readers will be given a rare opportunity to superimpose the latest conceptual innovations with the latest case study applications and from a diverse spectrum of organisational vantage points. This provides the myriad practitioners and consultants in this space with invaluable insights as to how to improve their trade craft, while ensuring policy makers and the accompanying research/academic industry have clearer guidance and innovative thinking. This edited volume provides critically innovative offerings for the audiences that make up this broad area’s practitioners, researchers/academics/educators, and consultants, as well as policy makers.
Between self-interest and solidarity: Norway’s return to UN Peacekeeping?
Norway has been a firm supporter of, and contributor to, UN peacekeeping operations. However, while increasing its financial support since the end of the Cold War, Norway has significantly downscaled its troop contributions to the UN, focusing on NATO operations. Rather than interpreting this as lessened interest in the UN, we point out that support and commitment cannot be measured solely in numbers of troops deployed. Norway’s commitment to UN peacekeeping should be understood as part of its strategic culture, here read as a synthesis between self-interest and solidarity, and between the UN and NATO. This article details the institutional, political and material challenges and opportunities for renewed engagement in UN peacekeeping.
Lifting the Fog of War? Opportunities and Challenges of Drones in UN Peace Operations
While the military use of drones has been the subject of much scrutiny, the use of drones for humanitarian purposes has so far received little attention. As the starting point for this study, it is argued that the prospect of using drones for humanitarian and other life-saving activities has produced an alternative discourse on drones, dedicated to developing and publicizing the endless possibilities that drones have for "doing good". Furthermore, it is suggested that the Good Drone narrative has been appropriated back into the drone warfare discourse, as a strategy to make war "more human". This book explores the role of the Good Drone as an organizing narrative for political projects, technology development and humanitarian action. Its contribution to the debate is to take stock of the multiple logics and rationales according to which drones are "good", with a primary objective to initiate a critical conversation about the political currency of "good". This study recognizes the many possibilities for the use of drones and takes these possibilities seriously by critically examining the difference the drones' functionalities can make, but also what difference the presence of drones themselves – as unmanned and flying objects – make. Discussed and analysed are the implications for the drone industry, user communities, and the areas of crisis where drones are deployed.
Relaterte prosjekter
Support to the 2015 Review of the UN's Peacebuilding Architecture
Prosjektets målsetting har vært å støtte gjennomgangen av FN's fredsbyggingsstruktur...
Peace Capacities Network: Peace Operations, Civilian Capacity and Security Sector Reform in a Changing World Order (PeaceCap )
Peace Capacities Network (PeaceCap) undersøker betydningen fremvoksende stormakter har for fredsoperasjoner, reform av sikkerhetssektoren og for sivile ressurser....
Rising Powers and Peacebuilding
Prosjektet Rising Powers and Peacebuilding tar opp viktige spørsmål som ennå ikke har blitt grundig undersøkt: hva er de fremvoksende maktenes tilnærminger til fredsbygging, hvordan skiller de seg fra...